• Login or Create Account
  • Currency

    AUD

You are booking hotel for more than 90 days

Hotels in Bay Shore are very affordable and a good option for staying in case you are planning a visit to Long Island. Below are some of the best hotels in Bay Shore offered by us for you to choose from. The rooms are very clean and comfortable with high-class amenities being provided to the guests. Book one from the below list of Long Island Hotels in Bay Shore at the best prices, starting from . Explore & book to grab exclusive deals and discounts now. Get Up to 20% (up to AED 400) Off* on hotel booking in Long Island with MakeMyTrip using coupon code : “SUPERSAVER” valid on 100,000+ Hotels. View More
map
Applied FiltersClear

Bay Shore

Locality

Popular locations

BACK TO TOP
Sort By
Popular
User Rating (Highest First)
Price (Highest First)
Price (Lowest First)
hotelImg
default backgrounddefault backgrounddefault backgrounddefault background

Courtyard by Marriott Long Island Islip/Courthouse Complex

 | 6.2 km from Bay Shore
Room, 1 King Bed with Sofa bed, Non Smoking
GymGym
Hurry! only last few rooms left at this price
Excellent4.4

Based on 723 Ratings

Cleanliness4.5

Room4.5

Hospitality4.4

(723 Ratings)

AUD 249

+ AUD 36 taxes & fees

Per Night

Login to Book Now & Pay Later!
hotelImg
default backgrounddefault backgrounddefault backgrounddefault background

Residence Inn Long Island Islip/Courthouse Complex

Long Island | 6.3 km from Bay Shore
Studio, 1 King Bed with Sofa bed (Mobility Accessible, Roll-in Shower)
Swimming PoolSwimming Pool
GymGym
Breakfast Included
Hurry! only 1 room left at this price
Excellent4.5

Based on 578 Ratings

Location4.3

Cleanliness4.6

Room4.5

Hospitality4.5

Value For Money4

(578 Ratings)

AUD 268

+ AUD 38 taxes & fees

Per Night

Login to Book Now & Pay Later!
hotelImg
default backgrounddefault backgrounddefault backgrounddefault background

Radisson Hotel Hauppauge-Long Island

Hauppauge | 9.2 km from Bay Shore
Room, 2 Double Beds, Non Smoking
SpaSpa
Swimming PoolSwimming Pool
GymGym
Free Cancellation till 24 hrs before check in
Hurry! only last few rooms left at this price
Good3.0

Based on 859 Ratings

Cleanliness3.2

Room2.7

Hospitality3.2

(859 Ratings)

AUD 241

AUD 215

+ AUD 31 taxes & fees

Per Night

Login to Book Now & Pay Later!
hotelImg
default backgrounddefault backgrounddefault backgrounddefault background

Whitman Motor Lodge

South Huntington | 17.4 km from Bay Shore
Standard Room, 1 King Bed
ParkingParking
Free Cancellation till 24 hrs before check in
Excellent4.4

Based on 964 Ratings

Location5

Cleanliness4.5

Room4.2

Hospitality4.5

(964 Ratings)

AUD 407

+ AUD 58 taxes & fees

Per Night

Login to Book Now & Pay Later!
hotelImg
default backgrounddefault backgrounddefault backgrounddefault background

Courtyard by Marriott Republic Aprt Long Island/Farmingdale

East Farmingdale | 15 km from Bay Shore
Room, 1 King Bed with Sofa bed, Non Smoking
GymGym
Hurry! only last few rooms left at this price
Excellent4.4

Based on 916 Ratings

Location4.5

Cleanliness4.6

Room4.5

Hospitality4.5

Value For Money4.1

(916 Ratings)

AUD 333

+ AUD 47 taxes & fees

Per Night

Login to Book Now & Pay Later!
hotelImg
default backgrounddefault backgrounddefault backgrounddefault background

Homewood Suites by Hilton Ronkonkoma

Ronkonkoma | 15.5 km from Bay Shore
6.9 km drive to Islip Airport, NY (ISP-MacArthur),
7 minutes walk to Ronkonkoma Station,
1 KING 1BDRM SUITE NONSMOK
Swimming PoolSwimming Pool
GymGym
Free Cancellation
Breakfast Included
Hurry! only last few rooms left at this price
Excellent4.5

Based on 372 Ratings

Cleanliness4.6

Room4.6

Hospitality4.6

(372 Ratings)

AUD 282

+ AUD 36 taxes & fees

Per Night

Login to Book Now & Pay Later!
hotelImg
default backgrounddefault backgrounddefault backgrounddefault background

Hilton Garden Inn Islip/MacArthur Airport

Ronkonkoma | 12.4 km from Bay Shore
3.7 km drive to Islip Airport, NY (ISP-MacArthur),
1 KING ACC RM W/BATHTUB
GymGym
Hurry! only last few rooms left at this price
Excellent4.8

(960 Ratings)

AUD 317

+ AUD 40 taxes & fees

Per Night

Login to Book Now & Pay Later!
hotelImg
default backgrounddefault backgrounddefault backgrounddefault background

Residence Inn by Marriott Long Island Holtsville

Holtsville | 19 km from Bay Shore
10.6 km drive to Islip Airport, NY (ISP-MacArthur),
Studio, 1 King Bed with Sofa bed
GymGym
JacuzziJacuzzi
Free Cancellation till 24 hrs before check in
Breakfast Included
Hurry! only last few rooms left at this price
Excellent4.4

Based on 819 Ratings

Location4.5

Cleanliness4.5

Room4.3

Hospitality4.5

Value For Money4.2

(819 Ratings)

AUD 293

+ AUD 42 taxes & fees

Per Night

Login to Book Now & Pay Later!
hotelImg
default backgrounddefault backgrounddefault backgrounddefault background

Marriott Melville Long Island

Long Island | 16.3 km from Bay Shore
Room, 1 King Bed with Sofa bed, Non Smoking (Mobility/Hearing Access, Roll-in Shwr)
Swimming PoolSwimming Pool
GymGym
Free Shuttle ServiceFree Shuttle Service
Free Cancellation
Hurry! only last few rooms left at this price
Very Good4.2

Based on 944 Ratings

Hospitality4.4

Room4.3

Cleanliness4.4

(944 Ratings)

AUD 370

+ AUD 53 taxes & fees

Per Night

Login to Book Now & Pay Later!
hotelImg
default backgrounddefault backgrounddefault backgrounddefault background

Residence Inn By Marriott Long Island Hauppauge

Hauppauge | 11.2 km from Bay Shore
Suite, 1 Bedroom
SpaSpa
Swimming PoolSwimming Pool
GymGym
Free Cancellation
Breakfast Included
Hurry! only last few rooms left at this price
Excellent4.3

Based on 347 Ratings

Location4.3

Cleanliness4.5

Room4.3

Hospitality4.6

Value For Money3.9

(347 Ratings)

AUD 370

+ AUD 61 taxes & fees

Per Night

Login to Book Now & Pay Later!
hotelImg
default backgrounddefault backgrounddefault backgrounddefault background

Hampton Inn Long Island / Commack

 | 10 km from Bay Shore
1 QN ACCESS TUB NONSMOK
Swimming PoolSwimming Pool
GymGym
Free Airport TransferFree Airport Transfer
Breakfast Included
Hurry! only last few rooms left at this price
Excellent4.3

Based on 955 Ratings

Cleanliness4.5

Room4.3

Hospitality4.5

(955 Ratings)

AUD 288

+ AUD 36 taxes & fees

Per Night

Login to Book Now & Pay Later!
hotelImg
default backgrounddefault backgrounddefault backgrounddefault background

Courtyard by Marriott Long Island MacArthur Airport

Ronkonkoma | 15.6 km from Bay Shore
7.2 km drive to Islip Airport, NY (ISP-MacArthur),
Room, 2 Queen Beds, Non Smoking (Mobility/Hearing Accessible, Tub)
Swimming PoolSwimming Pool
GymGym
JacuzziJacuzzi
Hurry! only last few rooms left at this price
Very Good4.2

Based on 926 Ratings

Location4.2

Cleanliness4.4

Room4.3

Hospitality4.4

Value For Money3

(926 Ratings)

AUD 249

+ AUD 35 taxes & fees

Per Night

Login to Book Now & Pay Later!
hotelImg
default backgrounddefault backgrounddefault backgrounddefault background

Four Points by Sheraton Melville Long Island

Plainview | 18.2 km from Bay Shore
Standard Room, 1 King Bed, Non Smoking (Shower Only)
Swimming PoolSwimming Pool
GymGym
JacuzziJacuzzi
Very Good4.2

Based on 866 Ratings

Location4.3

Cleanliness4.4

Room4.2

Hospitality4.4

Value For Money3.9

(866 Ratings)

AUD 218

+ AUD 25 taxes & fees

Per Night

Login to Book Now & Pay Later!
hotelImg
default backgrounddefault backgrounddefault backgrounddefault background

Hyatt Regency Long Island

Islandia | 11.6 km from Bay Shore
11.6 km drive to Islip Airport, NY (ISP-MacArthur),
Room, 1 King Bed
Swimming PoolSwimming Pool
GymGym
JacuzziJacuzzi
Free Cancellation
Hurry! only 1 room left at this price
Very Good4.1

Based on 895 Ratings

Cleanliness4.3

Room4.1

Hospitality4.2

(895 Ratings)

AUD 146

+ AUD 21 taxes & fees

Per Night

Login to Book Now & Pay Later!
hotelImg
default backgrounddefault backgrounddefault backgrounddefault background

TownePlace Suites by Marriott Republic Airport Long Island

East Farmingdale | 14.9 km from Bay Shore
Studio, 1 Queen Bed with Sofa bed (Mobility Accessible, Tub)
SpaSpa
GymGym
Breakfast Included
Hurry! only 1 room left at this price
Very Good4.2

Based on 477 Ratings

Location4.4

Cleanliness4.2

Room4.1

Hospitality4.4

Value For Money4.2

(477 Ratings)

AUD 285

+ AUD 41 taxes & fees

Per Night

Login to Book Now & Pay Later!
hotelImg
default backgrounddefault backgrounddefault backgrounddefault background

Come As You Are Inn

Long Island | 13.6 km from Bay Shore
6.5 km drive to Islip Airport, NY (ISP-MacArthur),
6 minutes walk to Sayville Station,
Homestay
| Sleeps 2 guests
The Ethel Merman Room
Swimming PoolSwimming Pool
Free Cancellation
Breakfast Included
Hurry! only 1 room left at this price
Excellent4.9

(46 Ratings)

AUD 542

+ AUD 77 taxes & fees

Per Night

Login to Book Now & Pay Later!
hotelImg
default backgrounddefault backgrounddefault backgrounddefault background

Hilton Garden Inn Melville

Plainview | 17.9 km from Bay Shore
Deluxe Room, 2 Queen Beds
GymGym
Free Shuttle ServiceFree Shuttle Service
Excellent4.3

Based on 943 Ratings

Cleanliness4.5

Room4.4

Hospitality4.4

(943 Ratings)

AUD 288

+ AUD 36 taxes & fees

Per Night

Login to Book Now & Pay Later!
hotelImg
default backgrounddefault backgrounddefault backgrounddefault background

Jake's 58 Casino Hotel - Adult Only

Islandia | 11.5 km from Bay Shore
11.4 km drive to Islip Airport, NY (ISP-MacArthur),
Basic Single Room
BarBar
Elevator/LiftElevator/Lift
ParkingParking
Free Cancellation till 24 hrs before check in
Very Good4.0

Based on 1111 Ratings

Cleanliness4.1

Room3.8

Hospitality4.2

(1111 Ratings)

AUD 225

+ AUD 32 taxes & fees

Per Night

Login to Book Now & Pay Later!
hotelImg
default backgrounddefault backgrounddefault backgrounddefault background

Best Western Bar Harbour Inn

East Massapequa | 17.7 km from Bay Shore
2 Double Beds, Non-Smoking, High Speed Internet Access, Coffee Maker, Hairdryer, Iron And Ironing Bo
GymGym
Free Cancellation till 24 hrs before check in
Breakfast Included
Hurry! only last few rooms left at this price
Very Good3.8

Based on 951 Ratings

Cleanliness3.9

Room3.7

Hospitality4.1

(951 Ratings)

AUD 340

+ AUD 40 taxes & fees

Per Night

Login to Book Now & Pay Later!
hotelImg
default backgrounddefault backgrounddefault backgrounddefault background

Hilton Long Island Huntington

 | 15.7 km from Bay Shore
Standard Room, 2 Double Beds
Swimming PoolSwimming Pool
GymGym
JacuzziJacuzzi
Average2.3

(946 Ratings)

AUD 286

+ AUD 41 taxes & fees

Per Night

Login to Book Now & Pay Later!

Properties In Long Island